Top 10 Rejected Peanut Butter Types September 27, 2017 by Slant Staff 10. Crusty 9. Dusty 8. Salt and Vinegar 7. Sour Cream and Onion 6. Peanut Butterface 5. Cool Ranch 4. Frozen 3. George Washington Carver Butter 2. Can’t Believe It’s Not Peanut Butter 1. Jelly